Polsinelli at Work Blog
- April 27, 2015
You Got To Know When To Hold ‘Em: Preserving Documents and Electronically Stored Information (ESI) in Class and Collective Actions
Timely preservation of documents and electronically stored information can be costly and challenging to implement, particularly when defending collective and class actions under the Fair Labor Standards Act and state wage & hour laws. The preservation duty evolves with each technological innovation integrated into the workplace. With advancing technology, more data relating to the manner of performance, frequency, and duration of disputed job duties is generated than ever. Drawing your preservation road map before litigation is imminent may minimize costs and reduce the risks of data spoliation. The preservation obligation is triggered when litigation is reasonably anticipated, which may pre-date the filing and service of a lawsuit, typically when an employee or counsel threatens to initiate a lawsuit. Once the preservation obligation is triggered, it is critical to define the appropriate scope of preservation of ESI. Failure to preserve sufficient information may result in a finding of spoliation, resulting in legal sanctions, adverse inferences, and potential forfeiture of legal defenses. On the other hand, over-preservation of ESI may unnecessarily divert company resources and disrupt business operations. The margins of error are often magnified in statewide class and nationwide collective actions, which can involve thousands (or more) of employees. There is little case law defining the appropriate scope of preservation in class and collective actions. General guideposts are provided by the maxims of proportionality and undue burden under Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 26 and the watershed Zubulakeadmonishment to preserve “what [a party] knows, or reasonably should know, is relevant to the action, is reasonably calculated to lead to the discovery of admissible evidence, is reasonably likely to be requested during discovery and/or is the subject of a pending discovery request.” Zubulake v. UBS Warburg LLC, 220 F.R.D. 212, 217 (S.D.N.Y. 2003). These principles, however, do not define the extent to which the preservation obligation extends to pled, but as yet uncertified, class and collective action allegations. Cf. Tracy v. NVR, Inc., No. 04-CV-6541L, 2012 WL 1067889, at *9 (W.D.N.Y. Mar. 26, 2012). This critical gap in the law requires employers to carefully consider any decision not to preserve data that may relate to a potential class member or opt-in plaintiff, and the data that may be overwritten in the ordinary course of business prior to a class or conditional certification motion or ruling. Arguably, preserving data for hundreds or thousands of employees who may potentially join a putative class or collective action is not proportional to the litigation value of such data until the plaintiff takes some action toward moving for class certification or joining putative opt-in plaintiffs in the lawsuit. However, a party’s unilateral assessment that preservation of data is not proportional to its probative value or poses an undue burden is not a sufficient justification to avoid preservation. One reported federal court decision counsels against using the “highly elastic concept” of proportionality as a shield to preservation in the absence of opposing counsel’s agreement on the scope of preservation or a court’s protective order. Pippins v. KPMG LLP, 279 F.R.D. 245, 255 (S.D.N.Y. 2012). Given the potentially substantial consequences of a wrongful failure to preserve, in the absence of definitive guidance, employers should address the preservation of documents and data consistent with the scope of class and collective allegations at the outset of a case, even where the plaintiff has not moved to certify those allegations. First, employers should identify the sources of potentially relevant ESI, which may require an iterative process of interviewing internal database custodians. Database custodians should also be consulted at the outset to determine whether any data readily preserved may nevertheless be unduly burdensome to produce for all members of the class and/or collective, due to the manner in which it is stored or other factors. As sources of potentially relevant ESI are identified, employers may avail themselves of several strategies to limit the scope of such ESI to preserve. Employers may seek opposing counsel’s consent on the scope of preservation, which may be defined in whole or part by any number of objective criteria, including a date range, office locations, a particular supervisor, or a random sample, among others. If consent is refused for ESI that is particularly burdensome to preserve, the employer may propose shifting the cost of preservation to plaintiff’s counsel. If cost shifting is refused, the employer may move for a protective order limiting the scope of preservation, even prior to any motion for certification of the putative collective or class action. Addressing these issues early in litigation may, no matter the outcome of the issue, pay dividends later in litigation, as the risk of spoliation may be greatly reduced through an agreement, stipulation, or court order on the scope of the employer’s duty to preserve. In the absence of such protective measures, employers will most likely bear the risk of not preserving data later requested in discovery and deemed discoverable (i.e., reasonably calculated to lead to the discovery of admissible information). As the scope of preservation is defined, the employer should expediently issue and enforce proper litigation hold memoranda and suspend procedures and processes that overwrite data to be preserved in the ordinary course of business. The litigation hold should be sent not only to “key players” with physical possession of potentially discoverable documents and information, but also to the custodians of databases containing potentially discoverable information. Early and detailed discussions with database custodians are essential in cases where the timing and duration of tasks on computers is at issue, as such data tends to be transient and, in some cases, difficult to extract from the aggregate data gathered by a computer system in the ordinary course of business. In summary, proactively tackling ESI preservation at the outset of a case generally pays dividends for employers, particularly employers facing class and collective action claims of statewide or nationwide scope. Given the legal tools at an employer’s disposal to limit the scope of preservation where a dispute arises, courts generally have little sympathy for employers that fail or delay to take steps to preserve discoverable data at the outset of a case. Experienced counsel can help to navigate these issues and pose solutions that minimize spoliation risks and burdens to businesses’ operations and bottom line.
- April 15, 2015
Alert: DOL Releases Controversial Proposal, Signifying Regulatory Intent to Expand Fiduciary Standard
On April 14, 2015, the U.S. Department of Labor (“DOL”) released a controversial proposal that would require financial advisors to put their clients’ interests ahead of their own when recommending retirement investments. Businesses and financial advisors that manage retirement investment accounts should be aware of the new rule and how it might affect their business. While speculation about the expansion of the so-called “Fiduciary Standard” has been rampant for years, yesterday’s release confirms that government regulators intend to expand the Fiduciary Standard. Specifically, the expansion will result in coverage of a larger number of financial advisors by closing two loopholes in the definition of “retirement investment advice.” Although firms would still be allowed to set their own compensation rates, the DOL’s proposed rule would: Establish a best-interest contract exemption that would legally require brokers to act in their clients' best interest and; Require brokers to disclose all conflicts of interest to their clients. To view the full alert, click here. To receive Polsinelli L&E alerts directly to your email, click here.
- April 13, 2015
Car, Boat, and Farm Equipment Dealership Service Advisors Exemption in Peril
Car, boat, and farm equipment dealerships that pay their service advisors on a salaried or commission basis should take note of a recent Ninth Circuit case holding that service advisors may not be exempt from overtime compensation under the Fair Labor Standards Act, potentially entitling those service advisors to overtime pay for all time worked beyond 40 hours in a week. Employers can expect to see an uptick in FLSA and state wage claims nationwide seeking to apply a narrow reading of the FLSA Dealership Exemption from overtime compensation. The FLSA Dealership Exemption exempts from overtime “any salesman, partsman, or mechanic primarily engaged in selling or servicing automobiles.” While the Dealership Exemption clearly exempts vehicle salespersons and mechanics from overtime pay, it does not directly address whether it applies to service advisors and other employees who solicit repairs, warranties, supplemental services, and parts. Several court rulings and a United States Department of Labor Opinion Letter from the 1970s applied the Dealership Exemption to service advisors. In 2011, the United States Department of Labor issued regulations defining the words “salesman,” “partsman,” and “mechanic” as used in the Dealership Exemption. On March 24, 2015, the United States Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit ruled in Navarro v. Encino Motorcars, LLC that service advisors were not covered by the exemption under these Department of Labor definitions interpreting the Dealership Exemption. The Court reasoned that because the Department of Labor’s regulations were a reasonable interpretation of an ambiguous statute, the Court was required to apply the Department of Labor’s regulations strictly as written, to exclude any employee not expressly described therein. Although the Ninth Circuit’s ruling on Navarro only applies to states within that judicial circuit (e.g., California, Oregon, Washington, Nevada, Montana, Idaho, Wyoming, Arizona, Hawaii, Alaska), the reasoning in Navarro may be adopted by courts nationwide addressing this issue for the first time. In addition, the Navarro opinion may inform courts interpreting state wage payment laws, which often apply the same or similar exemptions as the federal FLSA. Going forward, the Navarro ruling may be extended to dealership employees other than service advisors, who are not primarily engaged to sell vehicles, repair vehicles, or requisition, stock or dispense parts. Dealerships that pay such employees or service advisors on a salary or commission basis should consult with experienced employment attorneys to assess the effect of the Navarro ruling on their businesses and what steps may be taken to reduce the risk of future claims or potentially qualify such employees for other overtime exemptions.
- April 06, 2015
Alert: FMLA Rights Extend to Same Sex Spouses
The Department of Labor recently published its final rule amending the definition of “spouse” in the Family Medical Leave Act ("FMLA") regulations to include eligible employees in legal same-sex marriages. Beginning on March 27, 2015, same-sex spouses will be covered under the FMLA if the employee was legally married under the law of any state, regardless of the employee’s state of residency. To view the full alert, click here. To receive Polsinelli L&E alerts direct to your email, click here.
- Discrimination & HarassmentMarch 31, 2015
Alert: U.S. Supreme Court Reinstates Pregnancy Discrimination Suit Against UPS
On March 25, 2015, in a case that garnered significant attention from employers prior to hearing, the U.S. Supreme Court created by a 6-3 vote a new approach for proving and defending against pregnancy discrimination and accommodation cases. The Court's ultimate question – "Why, when the employer accommodated so many, could it not accommodate pregnant women as well?" – and subsequent ruling should provide insight for employers today. To view the full alert, click here. To receive L&E alerts direct to your email, click here to subscribe.